David Noble, modern Luddite

I suppose it’s a casualty of the job. There I was slated to summarize the life of this extraordinary individual when suddenly he was knocked off the grid. I pitched; my editor caught. I rounded up interviews, gathered research materials, read till my eyeballs ached and my brains tingled. And then, yesterday, I was told that no, The Globe will not be running a full obituary of David Noble.

So, here I am complaining a bit about that but mostly wanting to give space to this man while he still lives in my thoughts and while a few of his tomes share space on my literal desktop. Books, this man loved books. He wasn’t as fond of technology though and that was what he wrote about.

“The catastrophe of the second industrial revolution already rivals that of the first, only without the resistance.” [Progress Without People, Between the Lines, 1995] He says people now work longer hours, under worsening conditions, with greater anxiety and stress, less skills, less security, less power, less benefits, and less pay.

Those who are still working, says Noble, are the lucky ones.

“Where have all the jobs gone? Ask the printers, postal workers, bank tellers, telephone operators, office workers, grocery clerks, airline reservation agents, warehouse workers, autoworkers, steelworkers, dock workers–if you can find them.”

David Noble was a modern Luddite and wrote in defence of Luddism. Luddites followed their mythical leader, Ned Lud, during the first industrial revolution. They busted machines. Between 1811 and 1812, for example, manufacturing workers destroyed over one thousand mills in Nottingham, England.

‘Machine breaking’ was subsequently made a  capital crime by the Frame Breaking Act legislation which was opposed by Lord Byron, one of the few prominent defenders of the Luddites – and 17 men were executed after an 1813 trial in  York. Many others were transported as prisoners to Australia. At one time, there were more British troops fighting the Luddites than Napoleon I on the Iberian peninsula. I learned this in Wikipedia and the irony doesn’t escape me.

David Noble bemoaned the besmirching of Luddites that goes on today. He says the term “Luddite” became an epithet, a convenient device for disparaging and isolating the occasional opponent to progress.

“For to be called a Luddite meant that you were not really serious. It meant that you believed you could stop progress. It meant that you were crazy.”

Please, since he will be absent from the Globe & Mail obituaries page, read about David Noble’s life and work. It will astound you and his loss will be present for a long time to come.



About Nor

I'm a creative non-fiction writer, with a special interest in memoirs and obituaries--life stories, local histories with flesh & blood anecdotal details. I'm also beginning to create podcasts of people's stories and expanding their audiences. I'm a diarist, an editor, and a political activist. I live in Toronto, Ontario, Canada and spend days tapping keys or staining my fingers in ink.
This entry was posted in architecture, obituaries and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to David Noble, modern Luddite

  1. Henry says:

    Thanks a million Nor. So sorry you couldn’t complete the Globe piece.
    I’ll pass this on to other family members.
    Henry Noble

  2. Doug Noble says:

    I also greatly appreciate your comments here. I will surely let you know details of the memorial service for Dave. (Meanwhile, have a look at his World Without Women, my favorite of his works, but least known.) Thanks again. Doug

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s